Queersecrets Sucks

trbs:

Avoid: transman, transwoman, trans-man, trans-woman, etc.
Instead, use: trans man, trans woman, etc.
Why?: The one-word “transwoman” and hyphenated “trans-woman” imply that trans is a gender different from woman. The space indicates that it’s an adjective describing a woman, such as “Asian man”…

You know what’s even more interesting than my previous reply on this topic is that earlier tonight I was at a meeting of five FTM folk that agreed that “an FTM” is not only OK, but better than “trans man” or “trans male” because the latter do not describe all of them as accurately as “FTM”—and as a noun.

I am not binary gendered myself, so I will not try to claim that I completely understand the experiences of binary gendered trans men.

However, I have spoken to many-a trans man who feel completely insulted when they are referred to as anything other than “man” or “trans man”. Even “FTM” as an adjective was insulting to them, because they felt that the “F” has no place in their identity at all.  “An FTM” ungendered them further, by claiming their gender is not “male”, but defined by their trans status.  Because of their very valid reasoning and emotions, I am very opposed to the use of “FTM” or “MTF”, especially as nouns.

Are you and your friends similarly insulted by the use of “trans man” to describe your identity?

  1. sdi-aislinnbury reblogged this from 77825225672443
  2. pixyled reblogged this from 77825225672443
  3. justnodandsmile reblogged this from 77825225672443
  4. xthunderclapsx reblogged this from 77825225672443
  5. 77825225672443 reblogged this from queersecretssucks
  6. genderbitch reblogged this from pompadoursandpincurls and added:
    I’m not really upset. I’m using caps for emphasis. It’s a problem though because language influences thought. And it...
  7. pompadoursandpincurls reblogged this from genderbitch and added:
    hmmm. I see where you’re coming from, but I think it’s kind of overkill to get upset about a hyphen. I don’t really see...
  8. neutral-horror reblogged this from stfuhomophobes
  9. vladislava reblogged this from mytongueisforked
  10. rogerpirate reblogged this from stfusexists and added:
    had no idea there...transwoman/transman...trans woman/trans...
  11. theeoneandonlyknutt reblogged this from sugarysalvation
  12. sugarysalvation reblogged this from iragray
  13. adailyriot reblogged this from so-treu
  14. queersecretssucks reblogged this from iragray and added:
    I agree, so you can...up your own mind.
  15. bespangled reblogged this from so-treu
  16. zazzerzuzz reblogged this from sapphrikah
  17. someweretricksters reblogged this from stfuhomophobes and added:
    stfusexists: queersecretssucks:
  18. trbs reblogged this from queersecretssucks and added:
    Actually, yes. I don’t complain because my distinction is a really nitpicky difference between “guy” and “man,” but...
  19. jesuswasacommunist reblogged this from stfuhomophobes and added:
    oooh, I didn’t know of the difference between “transwoman/transman” and “trans woman/trans man” either. Helpful tip! :)